Which changes at Tencent flowed through to Prosus?
- Tencent’s 3Q26 revenue and operating profit were 2% and 6% below Goldman Sachs’ expectations, respectively, reflecting factors including weakness in overseas gaming and high AI spending; Tencent shares closed down 7% on 19 November.
- Tencent’s capital expenditure that quarter was RMB 65 billion, and free cash flow was negative at RMB 69 billion after including computing-power prepayments; excluding those prepayments, it was positive at RMB 17 billion. Meanwhile, Tencent said capital expenditure intensity had peaked, but Goldman Sachs largely maintained its capital expenditure forecasts and cut its adjusted net profit forecasts for Tencent FY27 and FY28 by 11% each.
- Growth in AI product users and usage coincided with widening investment losses: WorkBuddy’s daily active users exceeded 10 million, and its annualized revenue reached US$500 million, while losses on Tencent’s new AI products rose from RMB 10.5 billion in 2Q26 to RMB 15 billion in 3Q26.
How do Tencent’s changes reshape Prosus’s earnings and cash needs?
- Goldman Sachs cut its Prosus net profit and core EPS forecasts for FY28–FY31 by an average of 11% and 10%, respectively, while leaving its revenue, adjusted EBITDA and adjusted EBIT forecasts unchanged. Its net profit and core EPS forecasts for FY27 were instead raised by 3%, as it expects Tencent share sales to be slower than previously assumed.
- Prosus’s FY27 cash needs are about US$6.3 billion, including buybacks, dividends and acquisitions. The company has sold only about 30 million Tencent shares year to date, below the 120 million shares in FY26; Goldman Sachs expects it to make up the funding shortfall through about US$1.5 billion in sales of other assets and higher leverage.
- Operating assets also weigh on near-term earnings expectations: Goldman Sachs’ forecast for Prosus’s 1H27 adjusted EBITDA is 19% below the Visible Alpha consensus. It expects iFood to post a loss of US$5 million, versus consensus expectations for a profit of US$11 million; Goldman Sachs considers investment in Brazil to be more front-loaded. Tencent dividend income in FY28 is expected to be about US$100 million lower year over year, while an improving competitive environment in Brazil could increase cash flow from operating assets.
How large are the current net asset value discounts, and where do valuation differences lie?
- Based on Goldman Sachs’ sum-of-the-parts valuation, Prosus’s current net asset value discount is 36%, 2 percentage points narrower than its historical average of 38%; Naspers’s discount is 44%, 2 percentage points wider than its historical average of 42%. Both are close to their respective historical levels rather than significantly diverging from them.
- Valuations of operating assets are a key variable in measuring the discounts: Goldman Sachs values them at US$26.3 billion, 21% below the US$33.1 billion consensus compiled by the company. The difference mainly reflects iFood (US$4.1 billion versus US$6.4 billion) and Just Eat (US$2 billion versus US$3.8 billion). Using consensus valuations for those assets would put the Prosus and Naspers discounts at 40% and 46%, respectively.
What do the price-target cuts reflect?
- Goldman Sachs cut its 12-month price target for Prosus from €37 to €35 and maintained its Neutral rating; its Naspers price target fell from 813 rand to 781 rand. The Prosus target still applies a target net asset value discount of 35% and incorporates changes in Tencent’s valuation and earnings forecasts.
- The valuation is sensitive to the price assigned to Tencent shares: if Goldman Sachs’ Tencent price target, rather than Tencent’s current market capitalization, were used in Prosus’s sum-of-the-parts valuation, Prosus would be valued at €55 per share. This is the result under an alternative valuation assumption, not Goldman Sachs’ official price target for Prosus. Goldman Sachs also cites Tencent share-price performance, the extent of operating improvement in FY28, and whether operating assets can improve free cash flow as key variables.