By UnHideA Senior EditorsOriginal source:Goldman SachsFirst published on UnHideA:Original source date:
Key takeaway
LPL’s slower net new asset growth in October was mainly weighed down by a single large outflow, while the decline in cash balances was affected by the timing of quarterly fees; Stifel’s client asset growth coexisted with nearly flat net inflows, and client cash and Treasury deposits rose slightly.
Why were LPL’s net new assets weak?
LPL Financial Holdings reported net new assets of 7 billion dollars in October, equivalent to an annualized organic growth rate of 3.3%, broadly in line with the approximately 3% the company had mentioned in prior earnings communications. Goldman Sachs said the monthly figure was weaker than recently, mainly because a large client outflow offset a large inflow in August.
By business line, the advisory business had net inflows of about 8.2 billion dollars, while the brokerage business had net outflows of about 1.2 billion dollars; client assets at month-end were 2.561 trillion dollars, flat month over month and up 9% year over year.
Does the decline in client cash balances mean money flowed out?
LPL’s client cash balance fell from 56.6 billion dollars in September to 55.9 billion dollars in October, but Goldman Sachs attributed the decline to quarterly fees: those fees reduced the cash balance by 2.6 billion dollars. Excluding the fee impact, the estimated cash balance increased by 1.9 billion dollars, up about 3% month over month.
Thus, the decline in the month-end cash balance did not match the underlying cash trend; Goldman Sachs also noted that cash performance improved when the fee impact was excluded.
Why did Stifel’s asset growth not translate into greater net inflows?
Stifel Financial Corp.’s client assets were 578.9 billion dollars in October, up 0.4% month over month and 5.3% year over year. After incorporating an estimated market gain of 0.5%, Goldman Sachs estimated monthly net outflows of about 500 million dollars and an annualized organic growth rate of about -1%; by comparison, it estimated net outflows of 2.3 billion dollars and an annualized growth rate of -4.7% in September. Flows improved, but remained close to flat.
Cash items showed a mixed picture: client cash fell 1.3% month over month to 23.2 billion dollars, while deposits at the Treasury grew 4.2% to 13.2 billion dollars; together, the two totaled 36.4 billion dollars, up 0.6% month over month and 42.8% year over year. Net loans were 26.4 billion dollars, up 1.2% month over month and 21% year over year.
What are Goldman Sachs’ ratings on the two companies?
Goldman Sachs maintained its Buy rating on LPL, with a 12-month price target of 400 dollars, based on a price-to-earnings multiple of 13 times for the fifth through eighth quarters ahead. Listed downside risks include lower interest rates, weaker organic growth, slower growth in client cash, and a weaker stock market.
For Stifel, Goldman Sachs maintained its Neutral rating and 76-dollar price target, based on a price-to-earnings multiple of 11 times for the fifth through eighth quarters ahead; the report listed a weaker market and slower organic growth as downside risks.