Why were LPL’s net new assets weak?

  • LPL Financial Holdings reported net new assets of 7 billion dollars in October, equivalent to an annualized organic growth rate of 3.3%, broadly in line with the approximately 3% the company had mentioned in prior earnings communications. Goldman Sachs said the monthly figure was weaker than recently, mainly because a large client outflow offset a large inflow in August.
  • By business line, the advisory business had net inflows of about 8.2 billion dollars, while the brokerage business had net outflows of about 1.2 billion dollars; client assets at month-end were 2.561 trillion dollars, flat month over month and up 9% year over year.

Does the decline in client cash balances mean money flowed out?

  • LPL’s client cash balance fell from 56.6 billion dollars in September to 55.9 billion dollars in October, but Goldman Sachs attributed the decline to quarterly fees: those fees reduced the cash balance by 2.6 billion dollars. Excluding the fee impact, the estimated cash balance increased by 1.9 billion dollars, up about 3% month over month.
  • Thus, the decline in the month-end cash balance did not match the underlying cash trend; Goldman Sachs also noted that cash performance improved when the fee impact was excluded.

Why did Stifel’s asset growth not translate into greater net inflows?

  • Stifel Financial Corp.’s client assets were 578.9 billion dollars in October, up 0.4% month over month and 5.3% year over year. After incorporating an estimated market gain of 0.5%, Goldman Sachs estimated monthly net outflows of about 500 million dollars and an annualized organic growth rate of about -1%; by comparison, it estimated net outflows of 2.3 billion dollars and an annualized growth rate of -4.7% in September. Flows improved, but remained close to flat.
  • Cash items showed a mixed picture: client cash fell 1.3% month over month to 23.2 billion dollars, while deposits at the Treasury grew 4.2% to 13.2 billion dollars; together, the two totaled 36.4 billion dollars, up 0.6% month over month and 42.8% year over year. Net loans were 26.4 billion dollars, up 1.2% month over month and 21% year over year.

What are Goldman Sachs’ ratings on the two companies?

  • Goldman Sachs maintained its Buy rating on LPL, with a 12-month price target of 400 dollars, based on a price-to-earnings multiple of 13 times for the fifth through eighth quarters ahead. Listed downside risks include lower interest rates, weaker organic growth, slower growth in client cash, and a weaker stock market.
  • For Stifel, Goldman Sachs maintained its Neutral rating and 76-dollar price target, based on a price-to-earnings multiple of 11 times for the fifth through eighth quarters ahead; the report listed a weaker market and slower organic growth as downside risks.