What does the Australian equity valuation discount reflect?
- Based on Jefferies’ FY 1 (next fiscal year) forecasts, the S&P/ASX 200 Index has a P/E of 18.9 times, below the S&P 500 at 21.2 times and the Nasdaq at 25.6 times; it is also above the FTSE 100 at 12.7 times and the Hang Seng Index at 10.6 times. Australian equities are not cheap relative to every market.
- The valuation discount comes with lower earnings-growth expectations: forecast earnings growth for the ASX 200 Index is 12.9% and 8.3% for FY 1 and FY 2, respectively, compared with 33.0% and 14.7% for the S&P 500, and 42.9% and 30.6% for the Nasdaq. Therefore, a lower P/E than US equities does not mean a discount at equivalent growth rates.
Are earnings estimate revisions across Australian equities weakening across the board?
- The directions differ across sectors. Earnings estimate revisions for energy were +10.0% over the past 1 months and +35.1% over the past 12 months; for materials, they were -5.7% over the past 1 months and -12.7% over the past 6 months, but remained +10.1% over the past 12 months. Short-term downgrades and changes over a longer window do not point in the same direction.
- Earnings estimate revisions over the past 12 months were -20.5% for healthcare and +1.7% for financials. This shows that the valuation of the broad index cannot capture the earnings momentum of every sector; the differences between energy and materials are particularly worth watching.
How large are the sector gaps behind the index performance?
- As of the report’s statistical cutoff, the ASX 200 Index was up 2.2% year to date, less than the S&P 500 at 12.8%, the Nasdaq at 16.4% and the Nikkei 225 at 25.4%, but better than the Hang Seng Index at -8.8%. Australian equities’ overall returns were modest and lagged the strong performance of major overseas markets.
- Australian equities also showed clear divergence internally: the resources index was up 8.3% year to date, the industrials index was down 0.3%, the real estate investment trusts index was down 13.7%, and the small-cap index was down 16.4%. Their corresponding FY 1 P/Es were 14.3 times for resources and 21.5 times for industrials; forecast FY 1 earnings growth was 27.3% and 8.1%, respectively. Aggregate index data mask significant differences in sector performance and valuations.