How much of a demand downgrade is implied by the share-price decline?
- As of the report, ASML was down 25% over the past month and 17% over the past week, and fell 7% in a single day on 5 November. Morgan Stanley believes that, absent a semiconductor-industry downturn, the pullback overstates the weakening in AI investment.
- Based on a share price of 1,250 euros and a typical trough-period two-year forward P/E of 20 times, the market-implied FY28 EPS is 62.5 euros, about 20% below the Visible Alpha consensus estimate of 77.93 euros. With the firm’s assumptions for expenses, tax rates and other factors unchanged, and assuming several equipment businesses meet its expectations, the market-implied FY28 shipments of low-NA EUV tools are 93 units: 16% below Visible Alpha’s estimate and flat with Morgan Stanley’s FY27 estimate.
What operating signals support the firm’s contrarian view?
- Morgan Stanley says there are currently no signs of a slowdown in capacity expansion in DRAM, logic chips or foundries, and specifically points to TSMC’s progress on the A16 and A14 processes. The firm believes logic-chip investment may be more resilient than DRAM investment.
- The firm also acknowledges that the pace of DRAM expansion could flatten in 2027–2028. It also says customer investment plans remain on track and equipment pricing has improved; if concerns about AI infrastructure capacity ease, market expectations for equipment demand could be supported.
How was the 1,700 euro price target derived?
- Morgan Stanley bases its target on its FY28 EPS forecast of 68.47 euros and applies a P/E multiple of 25 times to arrive at a 1,700 euro price target. The 25-times multiple is near the midpoint of its 24–27-times mid-cycle valuation range.
- The firm reiterates its Overweight rating and Top Pick designation. The price target is based on the firm’s earnings forecast and a mid-cycle multiple, which are not the same assumptions as the 20-times trough-period multiple used to reverse-engineer the market-implied figure.
What could weaken this thesis?
- Capacity concerns continue to weigh on market expectations for equipment demand. If end demand weakens significantly, or inflation and a weakening Chinese economy lead customers to slow investment or defer orders, Morgan Stanley’s expansion view would be challenged.
- The firm also lists insufficient adoption of High NA technology in DRAM in 2028 and beyond as a valuation risk. In other words, the continuation of demand plans is one support for shipment expectations, while technology adoption and the pace of industry investment affect whether equipment demand materializes.