How far along are discussions of the tax reform, and which assumptions determine the estimates?

  • China is reportedly assessing whether to remove the corporate income tax exemption for interest income from central and local government bonds and tax it at the standard 25% rate. In October, the central bank sought views from some commercial banks on the impact, and the third-quarter monetary policy report also discussed the tax treatment of bonds. Whether the policy will be introduced and when it would take effect remain uncertain.
  • Goldman Sachs assumes that, following the bond value-added tax adjustment in 2025, outstanding bonds would be exempt, with the new tax regime phased in for newly issued bonds. The scope of the policy, arrangements for existing bonds, and whether public funds can retain a separate tax exemption would all affect the actual tax burden.
  • Goldman Sachs believes that broadening the tax base may be related to falling land-transfer revenues and rising fiscal funding pressures. If outstanding bonds are gradually replaced by new bonds as they mature and yields remain broadly unchanged, the additional tax revenue would be about 40 billion to 50 billion yuan in the first year, and annual revenue could reach 400 billion yuan after about 8 to 10 years.

Why does Goldman Sachs estimate 10–30 bp rather than a mechanical increase of 53 bp?

  • If investors were fully compensated for 25% corporate income tax through higher coupons, a 10-year government bond yielding 1.6% would need to rise to 2.13%, an increase of 53 bp. A 1-year government bond yielding 1.2% would need to rise to 1.6%, an increase of 40 bp. These are theoretical calculations for full compensation.
  • Goldman Sachs uses the restoration of value-added tax in 2025 as a benchmark. Based on the 10-year government bond yield of 1.75% at the time, full compensation for the 6% VAT would have been about 11 bp. The actual spread between new and old bonds was about 6 bp, equivalent to about 54% of the theoretical compensation. Applying the same ratio implies about 32 bp for the 25% corporate income tax, but the two types of tax may lead to different investor behavior.
  • Taking investor composition into account, Goldman Sachs puts the additional yield premium on newly issued taxable 10-year government bonds at 10–30 bp. It may initially be close to the upper end of the range, then ease as the market absorbs the change. If public funds continue to benefit from an income tax exemption, they may take up some taxable bonds, reducing the compensation demanded by taxable investors such as banks.

How much do recent spread movements tell us about the impact of the tax reform?

  • Interest on policy bank bonds held by domestic banks is already subject to 25% corporate income tax. Goldman Sachs therefore uses the spread between policy bank bonds and government bonds as a reference for the market-implied tax premium. The spread between the two types of 10-year bonds averaged about 6 bp before reports related to 11 November, and widened to about 11 bp afterward.
  • The widening of about 5 bp cannot be attributed entirely to the government bond tax reform. Goldman Sachs notes that credit repricing related to Huafa, as well as market concerns that public funds could lose their tax exemption and trigger targeted selling of policy bank bonds, also affected the spread.

How might the yield curve change, and what factors could offset the shock?

  • A higher tax burden would push up the yields required on newly issued government bonds, putting pressure on the curve to bear-steepen, with yields rising and the long end underperforming. Structural demand from institutions for long-duration assets could limit repricing at the long end; the central bank may also want to avoid an overly flat yield curve.
  • Goldman Sachs believes that, beyond the tax reform, weak growth momentum, subdued underlying inflation, and slowing credit growth continue to support long-dated government bonds. The upward pressure from the tax may therefore not dominate long-end performance on its own.

Further reading

Related topics