Key takeawayIn October, U.S. equities shifted from large-cap growth stocks toward small caps and value stocks. Jefferies attributed the shift to large-cap growth earnings failing to keep pace with valuations. Meanwhile, large-cap earnings forecasts were concentrated among a small number of companies, the earnings revision ratio was below 1, and credit spreads widened, limiting the durability of the style rotation.
Why did the shift from large-cap growth to small caps occur in October?
- Since the low on 14 October, the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index has rebounded by nearly 6 percentage points relative to the market-cap-weighted S&P 500, and is ahead by 2.85 percentage points year to date. The Russell 2000 has also started outperforming the Russell 1000 and the S&P 500 again, regaining its year-to-date lead.
- Jefferies believes the recent weakness was not driven by interest rates, but by earnings performance at large-cap, growth and AI-related companies failing to match their valuations. In October, defensive “bond proxy” stocks rose 4.2%, in contrast to pressure on growth stocks.
Is the return of value investing benefiting active funds broadly as well?
- From the start of the year through October, the performance gap between the Russell 1000 Value and Growth indices reached 2467 basis points, the widest in the first 10 months of the year; the gap between small-cap value and growth was about 11%, also well above average. On this basis, Jefferies believes that growth stocks’ three-year run of outperformance may be coming to an end.
- In October, 64% of the funds tracked by Jefferies outperformed their respective benchmarks, and the year-to-date share outperforming rose to 47%. But the year-to-date share of small-cap value funds outperforming was only 40%, and that of large-cap value funds was only 4%: improved performance in a single month did not translate into broad outperformance across active-fund categories.
Can earnings expectations support this style rotation?
- According to FactSet market expectations as of 30 October, earnings growth in 2026 is forecast at 14.5% for small caps, more than 21% for mid caps (with help from the energy sector), and 31.4% for large caps. However, the median earnings-growth forecast for large caps is only 10.6%, far below the aggregate growth rate of 31.4%, indicating that the overall forecast is being driven by a small number of high-growth companies.
- Although earnings expectations for Q4 were revised upward across the small-, mid- and large-cap groups, the earnings revision ratio has fallen below 1. Median earnings growth for small and mid caps in 2026 is forecast at 11.2% and 12.3%, respectively, with a smaller gap between the median and aggregate growth rates than for large caps.
Are small-cap valuations attractive even as the macroeconomic backdrop deteriorates?
- The forward price-to-earnings ratio for the Russell 2000 has fallen to 19.3, below the 20.7 for the Russell 1000. Jefferies’ relative-valuation model is at its 19th historical percentile. However, small caps’ absolute valuations remain at the 69th percentile, their cheapest reading since July 2025. Meanwhile, the relative-valuation model for value versus growth has risen to the 72th percentile, its highest since May 2018, indicating that value stocks are no longer cheap relative to growth stocks.
- Credit and interest-rate indicators pose another constraint: high-yield credit spreads rose to 359 basis points, a 52-week high, widening by 76 basis points from their level at the start of autumn. The yield-curve spread narrowed from its previous 73 basis points to 34 basis points. Jefferies said that if the curve continues to flatten, it would prompt the firm to reconsider its positioning.