Why does Morgan Stanley believe this pullback may be nearing its end?

  • Morgan Stanley views the current correction as the final phase of a mid-cycle transition: the S&P 500 is moving down toward weaker market breadth, while average individual-stock performance has improved, creating a divergence between the index and individual stocks.
  • Earnings-revision breadth has rebounded in a V-shape from its low; median-stock EPS growth in the Russell 3000 is at its strongest in four years. The firm expects returns in 2026 and 2027 to broaden to more stocks.
  • The firm maintains its year-end baseline of 8000 points for the S&P 500, while looking for sentiment indicators to provide further confirmation.

Can earnings support the index, and how much of a cushion does valuation provide?

  • Morgan Stanley’s non-PMI leading earnings model forecasts double-digit EPS growth. The firm believes earnings are driving the S&P 500 higher, even if valuations pull back.
  • As of 31 October 2026, estimates for S&P 500 earnings in 2026 had been revised up 19% over the past 12 months and 17% year to date. This reflects analysts raising their forecasts, not realized earnings growth.
  • On the other hand, the S&P 500’s equity risk premium over the next 12 months remains near historical lows, meaning valuations offer limited risk compensation; therefore, the 8000-point view depends more heavily on further improvement in earnings expectations.

Which sectors best illustrate the broadening of earnings growth?

  • Industrials are overweight: improvements in new orders, backlogs, and manufacturing indicators, alongside an earnings recovery, fiscal support, data-center construction, and manufacturing reshoring, are driving capital-expenditure growth. The sector still faces geopolitical and tariff risks.
  • Financials are overweight: the firm forecasts bank earnings growth of 14%, a forward P/E of about 12 to 13 times, and positive earnings-revision breadth. Loan growth and a recovery in M&A activity provide additional support.
  • Consumer exposure favors consumer discretionary over consumer staples. The firm is positive on spending by higher-income groups and an actual-income tailwind of about 65 billion dollars; however, consumer staples are weighed down by tariffs, commodity costs, and weakness among lower-income consumers.
  • Underweights in real estate and consumer staples reflect the firm’s preference for cyclical stocks and its view that a rolling recovery favors the relative performance of cyclical sectors. The technology sector remains equal-weight, although the firm considers the relative valuations of large cloud-service providers attractive; this has not led it to overweight technology across the board.

What conditions could constrain this outlook?

  • Financial conditions have taken on part of the Fed’s tightening burden, a point Chair Warsh has acknowledged to some extent, but he has not said that financial conditions are clearly in a “restrictive” state. This means the bar for a more dovish policy shift remains high, while liquidity is a risk the firm has flagged for 2027.
  • Historically, large-cap stocks have gained about 15% on average in the six months after U.S. midterm elections; Morgan Stanley also warns, however, that renewed escalation over Iran or changes in tariffs after the election could pose risks.
  • In this environment, the firm favors companies with durable cash flows, strong balance sheets, and improving earnings revisions, rather than those relying solely on a broad market rally.

Related topics