Key takeawayGoldman Sachs estimates that spot prices could significantly lift earnings at some miners, but sensitivity varies across the sector, its company earnings forecasts are below consensus, and commodity supply-demand outlooks diverge.
Which companies’ earnings would rise under the spot-price scenario?
- Based on the spot commodity prices and exchange rates listed in the report, compared with Goldman Sachs’ base case, BHP’s and Rio Tinto’s underlying EBITDA in 2029 would be 12% and 11% higher, respectively, while free cash flow would be 26% and 17% higher. These are differences between model scenarios, not changes in results reported by the companies.
- Sensitivity varies markedly among the companies covered: BlueScope Steel (BSL) would have underlying EBITDA at the end of 2029 that is 74% above Goldman Sachs’ base case, and free cash flow that is 139% higher—far larger increases than for BHP and Rio Tinto. Spot-price assumptions do not affect the earnings and cash flow of each company equally.
Why are Goldman Sachs’ earnings estimates still below market consensus?
- On a market-capitalization-weighted aggregate basis, Goldman Sachs’ revenue forecasts for the companies it covers for 2027–2029 are 1% below, 1% above and 2% above Visible Alpha consensus, respectively. Underlying EBITDA is 7%, 5% and 4% below, respectively, while net profit is 8%, 6% and 6% below. Revenue is broadly in line with consensus, but earnings forecasts are lower.
- Over the same period, Goldman Sachs’ operating expense forecasts are 5%, 7% and 8% above consensus, respectively. This set of forecasts indicates that the gap is not mainly in revenue scale, but in costs and expenses and their impact on profit.
What different signals do the copper, rare earth and lithium supply-demand models give?
- In Goldman Sachs’ model, the refined copper market remains in surplus in the near term: surpluses of 260 thousand tonnes and 210 thousand tonnes in 2026 and 2027, respectively, give way to a deficit of 180 thousand tonnes only in 2030. Meanwhile, copper demand for grids and power infrastructure is forecast to rise from 12.057 million tonnes in 2026 to 13.514 million tonnes in 2030, with electrification’s share increasing from 46% to 49%. This points to a gradual tightening, not an immediate shortage.
- The lithium model, by contrast, shows that supply remains ample: the global supply-demand balance is forecast to show a surplus of 28 thousand tonnes in 2026 and 150 thousand tonnes of LCE in 2027; the latter is equivalent to 7% of global supply. Even with demand including inventory replenishment growing 24% in 2026 and 8% in 2027, supply still exceeds demand.
- The outlook for rare earths is the opposite. Goldman Sachs’ supply-demand model for neodymium-praseodymium oxides shifts from a surplus of 4 thousand tonnes in 2025 to a deficit of 32 thousand tonnes in 2026. The deficit is forecast to widen to 156 thousand tonnes by 2035, supporting the view that supply will tighten over the medium term.
Is Goldman Sachs’ view on individual stocks one-sided?
- No. The report lists Buy ratings on BHP, RIO, BSL, CIA, ILU and LYC, and Sell ratings on FMG and NHC. Alongside the differences in companies’ earnings sensitivity under the spot-price scenario, this coverage summary reflects stock selection rather than a uniformly bullish view on Australian resource stocks.