Has the share of active funds outperforming increased this year?
- For year-to-date 2026, as reported, 42% of large active mutual funds have outperformed their respective benchmarks, above the historical average of 37%; the share of large growth funds outperforming is 81%, its highest in more than a decade. Value funds have had the strongest absolute returns year to date, at about 14%, but only 4% have outperformed their benchmarks, showing that strong absolute returns do not necessarily mean outperformance relative to a benchmark.
- Fund flows and active-fund performance are two distinct sets of data: as of 11 November, U.S. active equity mutual funds had seen year-to-date outflows of about 350 billion U.S. dollars and were heading toward a 12th consecutive year of net outflows; U.S. equity ETFs had inflows of about 960 billion U.S. dollars over the same period. Mutual-fund cash as a share of assets stood at 1.1% at the end of September, matching the record low in December 2025.
Does the narrower AI underweight mean funds are shifting wholesale into AI?
- Not a wholesale shift. Excluding mega-cap tech stocks, AI-related stocks account for 12% of the average large-fund portfolio, still an underweight of 130 basis points versus the benchmark; that underweight narrowed by 44 basis points from Q2. Including AI-related mega-cap stocks, the average fund holding is 34%, compared with 40% for the benchmark, leaving an overall underweight of 600 basis points.
- Buying is also concentrated in a subset of stocks: AMD, Palantir, Sandisk and Western Digital were among the stocks funds added to most in Q3. Meanwhile, the overall Mag 7 underweight was 722 basis points, little changed from 724 basis points in the previous quarter; Amazon was the only constituent with an average overweight position, for the first time since 2016. By number of shares held, funds made net reductions in every Mag 7 company except Microsoft, with the largest reductions in Alphabet, Google's parent, and Apple.
Which sectors did funds add to and trim?
- At the end of Q3, funds were overweight industrials and health care by 200 and 199 basis points, respectively; health-care allocation rose to a ten-year high. Goldman Sachs linked the popularity of health care to its negative correlation with the AI trade: when AI stocks are volatile, health-care stocks become another option in fund allocations.
- Information technology remained the most underweight sector, at 631 basis points, but funds added 29 basis points from Q2, mainly through software and semiconductors. Financials were overweight by 196 basis points, but funds reduced the overweight by 35 basis points from the previous quarter, with banks seeing the largest reduction. The sector data show selective adjustments, not uniform buying or selling.
Why has the market environment favored fund outperformance?
- Goldman Sachs noted that funds tend to have an easier time generating excess returns when individual-stock returns vary widely and market breadth is not narrow. Since Q4, market breadth has improved, partly as laggards caught up and partly as the largest stocks by market capitalization edged lower; dispersion in individual-stock returns remains high. Together, these conditions have provided a more favorable environment for active stock selection.
- The fund overweight basket, constructed using Q3 holdings, rose 5% since Q4, while the equal-weighted S&P 500 index rose 3% over the same period; the fund underweight basket fell 7%. Each basket contains 50 stocks, is equally weighted and is not sector-neutral. It therefore reflects the period performance of the relevant holdings baskets, not the actual returns of all active funds, and cannot on its own be considered a measure of stock-selection contribution.