Why might CTA position cuts ease selling pressure on futures?
- As of 18 November, net long CTA positions in Nikkei futures had fallen nearly 55% from their recent highs in late October, bringing positioning to a level not seen since October 2025. JPMorgan estimates that the portion of position cuts that might otherwise have been triggered if the Nikkei fell below 57,800 points had largely been completed in advance, before that level was actually breached.
- 57,800 points is the average cost of the net long positions built since October 2025, according to the bank's estimate. Early position cuts have reduced the risk of a chain decline triggered by CTA selling after a break below that level, but have not eliminated the possibility of further weakness in the index.
What conditions are needed for support near 57,800 points?
- JPMorgan notes that changes in the Nikkei's EPS over the next 12 months broadly track the trend in US core capital goods orders; therefore, whether CTAs continue to cut futures longs is linked to US capital expenditure, particularly data-center construction.
- In the bank's view, even if US capital investment slows from this year's pace, Japanese equities' EPS growth could remain around its historical average as long as investment still grows by about 5% to 8% year on year at an annualized rate. If earnings growth holds at this “cruising speed,” 57,800 points could serve as near-term support; the likelihood of a recovery toward around 60,000 points after consolidation would increase, but the bank believes it was still too early at the time to reach a conclusion.
Why might the index rebound remain weak even as futures selling pressure eases?
- On 18 November, the Nikkei briefly fell below 58,000 points intraday and closed at 59,024 points; the TOPIX stood at 3,824 points, still below the CTA key positioning level of around 3,890 points cited by JPMorgan. The bank believes it is still too early to conclude that the Nikkei has bottomed, and remains cautious about a break below 57,800 points.
- Reversals in spot-market positioning are still under way. As of 17 November, measured by three-month position profit and loss, 100% of long semiconductor positions were in “pain,” as were 93% of bank stocks; the share of short bank positions in this state also reached 100%. Profit-taking on longs and covering of shorts are occurring at the same time, and may cause supply-and-demand disruptions at the stock-selection level to weigh on the index; semiconductor and bank stocks may also be vulnerable to pressure during a near-term rebound.
Where is capital shifting, and when might a reversal become apparent?
- JPMorgan believes the current shift in capital toward quality companies at a reasonable price (QARP) mainly reflects the market's reduction of momentum and high-beta exposure as earnings return to normal, rather than a straightforward bet on recession. Lower-risk sectors with stronger QARP characteristics, such as insurance, healthcare, and media and entertainment, are relatively favored; within healthcare, the “pain ratio” for long pharmaceutical stocks was 0%, while that for short medical-device stocks was 100%.
- As of 17 November, media sentiment related to AI and semiconductors was near a new low. JPMorgan believes sentiment may bottom after the market digests Nvidia's results and that week's large US IPO, and as news fueling pessimism diminishes; this does not mean optimism will immediately take over and drive a rapid rebound in AI-related stocks.
- The bank views late November to early December as a period to watch, focusing on three developments: whether US data-center investment can support EPS growth, whether pessimism about AI has bottomed, and whether the spot market's “pain trade” has ended.